Uncommon Knowledge: Mamdani vs. Trump: Who Will Win the O...

...

By Newsweek StaffShareNewsweek is a Trust Project member

New York’s Mayor-elect Zohran Mamdani meets President Donald Trump in the Oval Office today, an encounter that brings together America’s two most successful politicians of the past year, after establishment-toppling election victories that echoed around the world. Much is known about the two men; yet, age, ideology, mass appeal, and formal power are not the only features that define their dynamic. Mamdani and Trump come to the meeting with unique strengths and weaknesses that are likely to define coverage of their relationship—and political polarization in America—for the next three years.

The meeting is an extremely rare event. Since the Great Depression only three New York Mayors are documented to have visited the White House before their inauguration—always in the context of major federal policies that touched the nation’s largest city. Fiorella LaGuardia visited the Roosevelt White House during the New Deal, John Lindsay during Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society initiative and Michael Bloomberg went to see George W. Bush after 9/11. No such overarching policy challenge hangs over the Trump-Mamdani meeting.

Common Knowledge

The two politicians are polar opposites in every way imaginable. Mamdani, 34, is the second-youngest mayor in New York’s history if records are reliable. Trump, 45 years older, is the second-oldest U.S. president and will leave office as the oldest if he serves a full four years. Mamdani is a Democratic Socialist who has denounced Trump as a dictator and oligarch. Trump is a right-wing populist who has denounced Mamdani as a communist and a dangerous Islamic radical. Trump embraces Israel, courts Evangelicals and Catholics and touts tax cuts for the working class. Mamdani is unapologetically Muslim, ferociously anti-Zionist and wants to see billionaires like Trump taxed into oblivion.

And yet they have much in common. Both have run stunning outsider election campaigns and triumphed over their party’s elites. Both have mastered social media and tamed traditional media. Both embrace controversy rather than shy away from it. Both have loyal bases that hate each other, and yet many New Yorkers who voted for Trump in 2024 voted for Mamdani a year later. Both captivated Gen Z voters with their campaigns. And Trump and Mamdani are two of the most famous New Yorkers alive today.

Partisans everywhere will view the Oval Office meeting as an unequal contest. MAGA fans will expect the most powerful politician in the world to spatter the upstart mayor like a bug, just as he did Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky. Mamdani warriors hope to see their smiling, smooth-talking hero skewer the aging president with principled barbs, just as he vanquished former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo.

Uncommon Knowledge

What is less well known is how both men—gifted politicians and culture war icons—are equally vulnerable to the setting, the timing and coverage of the meeting, as well as their opponent’s unique strengths.

The media coverage

On the face of it, this should be a Mamdani strength. The on-message mayor-elect tends to get much more sympathetic coverage from mainstream media reporters who dominate the White House press corps. And yet, the picture is more complicated. Mamdani’s team has repeatedly cut short contentious public and press engagements, giving him a reputation for evasiveness. They won’t be able to save him in the Oval Office. The press corps does have right-wing journalists who are as hostile to Mamdani as their competitors are to Trump. Trump’s handling of hostile media is famously successful by the standards he has set. He’s more accessible to the media than any president in history and launches ferocious attacks on hostile journalists. If that happens, Mamdani might not be much more than a footnote to coverage of the meeting.

The cut and thrust of debate

On the face of it, a Trump strength. After all who wants to take on the world’s greatest counterpuncher on his home turf. And yet, if this meeting devolves into a verbal cage match, Mamdani could walk away the winner. His incredible message discipline more than makes up for a lack of experience. His smiling delivery of perfectly honed counterpoints could easily derail the president who always takes the bait and never ever stops digging. Couple that with Trump’s vulnerability to proper fact-checking and this encounter becomes Mamdani’s to lose.

Charm offensives

Surely, the always-calm, always-smiling Mamdani is going to win any head-to-head charm contest. Not so fast. Trump can be very charming when he wants to be. And he has impeccable comic timing that works much better in the room than in the media coverage. And Trump has nothing to lose from being friendly, even solicitous to Mamdani. His base gives him space to do that to his opponents, even if it means lavishing praise on a former terrorist who has just become the leader of Syria. Mamdani has less room for maneuver. Barack Obama, Jimmy Fallon, Bill Maher, and Gretchen Whitmer are on a long list of public figures who have taken heat from the left for treating Trump in a way that “normalizes” him. A charming Trump will definitely make Mamdani squirm.

Social Media

This is a much closer contest. Mamdani is a social media rock star whose engagement rate on Instagram is 6 percent, far higher than most political accounts. And his mastery of TikTok with more than 3 million followers and videos primed for virility make him a powerful competitor to Trump, one of the dominant figures of the social media age. Trump is a TikTok lightweight by comparison, but an absolute powerhouse across other platforms, generating 2 billion impressions on X and adding more than 80 million followers on his Facebook page in the first 100 days of this term. Both are great at capturing the viral moment, but Mamdani’s strength comes from the depth of his engagement, presenting himself as a “friend in your feed” rather than a political messenger. Trump, conversely, excels at generating massive reach and dominating conversations across platforms, something that may be easier to do in an Oval Office confrontation.

Achilles’ heel issues

Trump is less vulnerable on the issues than he was during Mamdani’s campaign. The ceasefire in Gaza has blunted some of Mamdani’s most potent attacks. And Trump’s volte-face on the release of sex offender Jeffery Epstein’s files, has made him less vulnerable to provocation on that issue. But Trump is still triggered by the team “affordability,” having run on the rising cost of living in 2024 only to see his party suffer setbacks in elections this month after the Democrats seized on the issue. Mamdani ran on affordability, masterfully messaging his proposition to voters in New York and is almost sure to bring it up. Watch Trump take the bait.

Mamdani, unlike Trump, hardly ever takes the bait and stays on message. If he has an Achilles’ heel, it is around the fate of the Democratic Party’s current leadership. Mamdani’s wing of the party is now openly calling for Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer to stand down. Mamdani cut short a post election interview when he was asked about Schumer’s future. Team Trump probably noticed that.

If you’re enjoying Uncommon Knowledge, please share. If you have suggestions for future editions or feedback, email [email protected]. We want to hear your voice.

Request Reprint & LicensingSubmit CorrectionView Editorial & AI Guidelines